Next: A Brief History


Introductory Lecture

I would like to begin by outlining the structure of the course. (Schedule, assignments, resource files, reading list.) I take a hard line on due dates; an assignment drops one letter grade for every day late. I have tried giving flexible assignment dates in the past, and it always results in my getting 200 essays on the last day of term, all of which have been written in the previous 48 hours. This is not because engineering students are irresponsible or bad at planning; on the contrary, it's because they're logical. And, being logical, they can deduce the necessary conclusion from two simple axioms:

AXIOM 1: An assignment due tomorrow takes precedence over an assignment due next week

AXIOM 2: There is always an assignment due tomorrow

In this lecture, I'd like to briefly review what we'll be doing in the rest of the course. My chief objective in this course will be to persuade you to drop engineering, or, for the more senior students, to make you wish that you had dropped engineering. There are some pragmatic reasons for this -- to reduce the teaching load on our overworked faculty, for example -- but my chief motive is simply honesty. For the fact is that Engineering Science does not exist. Now, I know some of you have been taking courses in Chemistry and Physics; isn't this science, you ask? Well, yes, it is; engineers use the results of the sciences when they do engineering; but that doesn't make them scientists, any more than driving a car makes you a mechanic, or eating lunch makes you a chef. A scientist is someone who discovers scientific truth, not just someone who makes use of it.

Well, some may say there's nothing wrong with this; we can see engineering science as drawing on the results of all the sciences, and won't our engineers be all the smarter as a result? This is all very well, but there's a problem, namely, our current engineering faculty. if engineering science is a subject built from the sciences, who should be teaching it? Not these guys, that's for sure; they've never made a scientific discovery in their lives. They're just engineers, users of science. Why should you get your science at third hand from them, when you could be getting it live from real scientists? If engineering science is a science, it should be offered by the science departments.

In fact, the situation is even worse than I have been describing. The engineering faculty, non-scientists with a history of industrial involvement, are not merely incompetent to teach science; they actually have a corrupting effect upon it. Let me quote from Pierre Duhem, the historian and philosopher of science, writing in The Aim and Structure of Physical Theory: he contrasts English and French approaches to physics. He characterises English approach as suited to `ample minds', meaning that the English are capable of considering many things at once, but none in depth. He complains of the vogue for `English physics', by which he means accounting for phenomena by ad hoc models, rather than as logical consequences of some deep explanatory principle. An example of the abuse of ad hoc models in engineering education would be for us to present a course dealing with the laws governing the flow of fluid in pipes, then a course covering the laws governing flow over an aerofoil -- and never to look for the brief, difficult and precise description of a fluid from which all these laws can be deduced, as rigorously as a theorem can be deduced from its axioms. The slide towards ad hoc, `English' science, says Duhem, results from the bad influence of engineering upon science: ``The industrialist has very often an ample mind; the need to combine machinery, to deal with business matters and to handle employees has early accustomed him to see clearly and rapidly complicated assemblages of concrete facts. On the other hand, his is nearly always a very shallow mind. His daily pre-occupation keeps him removed from abstract ideas and general principles. Gradually the faculties constituting strength of intellect have atrophied in him, as happens with organs no longer functioning. The English model cannot, therefore, fail to appeal to him as the form of physical theory most appropriate to his intellectual attributes.

``Naturally, he desires to have physics expounded in that form to those who will have to direct workshops and factories. Besides, the future engineer requires instruction in a short time; he is in a hurry to make money with his knowledge, and he cannot waste time, which for him is money; ... Those who are commissioned to teach engineering are therefore eager to adopt the English methods and teach this sort of physics, which sees even in mathematical formulae nothing but models. The most glaring paralogisms and the falsest calculations are piled up in broad daylight; under the influence of industrial instruction, theoretical physics has become a perpetual challenge to the integrity of the accurate mind.

``For the evil has not only touched the texts and courses intended for future engineers. It has penetrated everywhere, propagated by the hatreds and prejudices of the multitude of people who confuse science with industry, who, seeing the dusty, smoky and smelly automobile, regard it as the triumphal chariot of the human spirit. Higher education is contaminated with utilitarianism. Abstract and deductive theories are rejected in favour of offering students concrete and inductive views. We no longer think of putting into young minds ideas and principles, but rather numbers and facts."

Duhem's objects to `English' physics because he wants truth, whereas `English' physics, or engineering physics, offers only useful lies. For example: for the civil engineer, the Earth is an infinite plane; for the aerospace engineer plotting the trajectory of a deep space probe, the Earth is a dimensionless point. And it never occurs to either of them to ask, ``What shape is the Earth really?''.

Duhem's own response: the simple but false equation sooner or later becomes, by an unexpected act of revenge of logic, the undertaking which fails, the dike which bursts, the bridge which crashes; it is financial ruin when it is not the sinister reaper of human lives

``Finally we shall declare to the utilitarians, who think they are making practical men by teaching only concrete things, that their pupils will sooner or later become routine manipulators, mechanically applying formulae they do not understand; for only abstract and general principles can guide the mind in unknown regions and suggest to it the solutions of unforeseen difficulties."

Well, we could ask our colleagues from physics to teach the abstract and general principles underlying physics, and we will teach the abstract and general principles underlying engineering. But what principles are these? Are there any? Well. of course there aren't, because engineering isn't a science; and for that point of view I shall now present further evidence:

Let us look at an illustrative list

Column A Column B
Physics Creation Science
Chemistry Domestic Science
Biology Political Science
Cosmology Engineering Science

Etymology --scientist, from scio, to know; one who knows; one who is concerned with the discovery of truth.

Now clearly, if you happened to be employed by MDA, and your boss coming into the office one day chances to ask you what you're doing, and you reply that you are seeking to enlarge humanity's knowledge of the truth, he may not rush to applaud your efforts; because discovering the truth is only incidentally part of the job of an engineer. If we look at the OED, we find that an engineer is ``one who contrives, designs or invents; an inventor, a plotter, a layer of snares''.

In short, the task of a scientist is to understand the world; the task of the engineer is to change it; and to change it requires strategy, requires cunning. And this is the distinctive subject matter of engineering; strategies for changing and controlling the world.

One of the surest indications of this difference is in professional examinations. Every engineer who wants to practice in BC must pass an exam in engineering ethics before qualifying. No physicist has to do this. Why is this? It is not because physicists are so noble that their ethics can be trusted without benefit of an exam, nor because engineers are so debased that they must be kept under close scrutiny. No, the ethics of the engineer matter because the engineer is charged with doing something; with changing the world in some way.

Admittedly, scientists have also caused changes in the world, by introducing new knowledge. But these changes have most commonly been unanticipated and unwanted side-effects of their research, from which they might wish to separate themselves -- as Einstein said towards the end of his life, ``If I had only known, I would have become a plumber." We excuse Einstein from Hiroshima. But we do not excuse the engineer whose bridge falls down or whose circuits fail. Their responsibility extends all the way through their actions.

The engineer alters the world, creates new things in the world. This is not science. A badly made watch and a well-made one both equally obey the laws of physics. But then, science is not all the engineer needs. He or she needs strategy. A strategy is not true or false; it is only more or less effective. What is strategy? Is it one subject or many? Does it have principles similar to the laws of physics? How can it be taught? For, as Duhem said, education in the sciences does not consist in memorising any list of scientific facts, but in learning to understand and apply a few deep principles which underlie physical phenomena. What deep principles underlie engineering?


Power Point Presentation


Next: A Brief History



John Jones
Wed Sep 10 2003